9337 1993-94 503 Rhodri Morgan 1994-02-01 That this House calls on the Secretary of State for Wales to sack the Chairman of South Glamorgan Health Authority, Ian Grist, and its General Manager, Gordon Harrhy, for their abuse of their public office in their attempt to stitch up Ian Mackie, consultant orthopaedic surgeon at the Treatment Centre at the Prince of Wales Orthopaedic Hospital, Rhydlafor, Cardiff, because he spoke out against the use of the untried and untested Zimmer replacement hip joint, by suspending him on full pay since last June and then dropping the charges against Mr Mackie on the first day of the disciplinary inquiry; believes that if the Chairman and the General Manager thought the charges were serious enough to suspend Mr Mackie, they were serious enough to be heard in full, and if they were not serious enough to be put to the test, they were too trivial to justify suspending Mr Mackie for seven months; disapproves strongly of the gagging clause signed by both sides, preventing public representatives from discovering the full truth; but believes that the collapse of the case against Ian Mackie has also caused the collapse of the public reputations of the Chairman and the General Manager, whose time is clearly now up. Rhodri Morgan 1994-02-01 Proposed Cardiff West Alan Wynne Williams 1994-02-02 Signed Carmarthen Harry Barnes 1994-02-02 Signed North East Derbyshire Paul Flynn 1994-02-02 Signed Newport West John Evans 1994-02-02 Signed St Helens North Jim Dowd 1994-02-02 Signed Lewisham West John Cummings 1994-02-02 Signed Easington Michael Connarty 1994-02-02 Signed Falkirk East Dennis Skinner 1994-02-02 Signed Bolsover Mike Hall 1994-02-03 Signed Warrington South Tommy Graham 1994-02-03 Signed Renfrew West and Inverclyde Bill Etherington 1994-02-03 Signed Sunderland North Tom Cox 1994-02-03 Signed Tooting Ronnie Campbell 1994-02-03 Signed Blyth Valley Roland Boyes 1994-02-03 Signed Houghton and Washington William McKelvey 1994-02-03 Signed Kilmarnock & Loudoun John McAllion 1994-02-03 Signed Dundee East Alan Simpson 1994-02-03 Signed Nottingham South Ernie Ross 1994-02-03 Signed Dundee West Bill Michie 1994-02-07 Signed Sheffield, Heeley Win Griffiths 1994-02-07 Signed Bridgend Janet Anderson 1994-02-07 Signed Rossendale & Darwen Ian Davidson 1994-02-08 Signed Glasgow, Govan Kim Howells 1994-02-08 Signed Pontypridd Martin Redmond 1994-02-09 Signed Don Valley Eddie Loyden 1994-02-10 Signed Liverpool, Garston Ken Livingstone 1994-02-10 Signed Brent East Eric Illsley 1994-02-10 Signed Barnsley Central Allan Rogers 1994-02-10 Signed Rhondda Martyn Jones 1994-02-15 Signed Clwyd South West Mike Gapes 1994-02-15 Signed Ilford South John Gunnell 1994-02-16 Signed Leeds South and Morley Jack Thompson 1994-02-16 Signed Wansbeck