27142 2004-05 800 David Clelland 2005-02-28 That this House believes that a partly elected second chamber would be an unsustainable hybrid and would inevitably lead to a fully elected chamber and that an elected second chamber could not guarantee the spread of experience, knowledge, background, gender and ethnicity required for a chamber dedicated to the scrutiny and advisory role hitherto considered appropriate for a reformed House of Lords; further believes that a second chamber should add value to our system of governance and be more representative and more effective and that these qualities can be achieved without producing a whole new batch of elected politicians; and believes that the cobbled together proposals outlined in the recently published Second Chamber of Parliament Bill are a disappointing response to the opportunity that now presents itself. David Clelland 2005-02-28 Proposed Tyne Bridge Labour Edward Garnier 2005-02-28 Signed Harborough Conservative Dennis Turner 2005-03-01 Signed Wolverhampton South East Labour Co-operative George Foulkes 2005-03-01 Signed Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley Labour Co-operative Ronnie Campbell 2005-03-01 Signed Blyth Valley Labour Bill Olner 2005-03-01 Signed Nuneaton Labour Kali Mountford 2005-03-01 Signed Colne Valley Labour John McWilliam 2005-03-01 Signed Blaydon Labour Siobhain McDonagh 2005-03-01 Signed Mitcham & Morden Labour Kevan Jones 2005-03-01 Signed North Durham Labour Brian Jenkins 2005-03-01 Signed Tamworth Labour Gerald Howarth 2005-03-01 Signed Aldershot Conservative Alan Howarth 2005-03-01 Signed Newport East Labour Stephen Hepburn 2005-03-01 Signed Jarrow Labour Tom Harris 2005-03-01 Signed Glasgow, Cathcart Labour Colin Pickthall 2005-03-01 Signed West Lancashire Labour Ross Cranston 2005-03-02 Signed Dudley North Labour Piara S Khabra 2005-03-02 Signed Ealing, Southall Labour Ernie Ross 2005-03-02 Signed Dundee West Labour Marion Roe 2005-03-02 Signed Broxbourne Conservative Si 2005-03-03 Signed Birmingham, Erdington Labour Calum MacDonald 2005-03-04 Signed Na h-Eileanan an Iar Labour Sydney Chapman 2005-03-07 Signed Chipping Barnet Conservative Syd Rapson 2005-03-08 Signed Portsmouth North Labour David Trimble 2005-03-09 Signed Upper Bann UUP Roy Beggs 2005-03-09 Signed East Antrim UUP Janet Anderson 2005-03-09 Signed Rossendale & Darwen Labour Jim Dowd 2005-03-09 Signed Lewisham West Labour Tom Cox 2005-03-09 Signed Tooting Labour David Burnside 2005-03-09 Signed South Antrim UUP Martin Smyth 2005-03-09 Signed Belfast South UUP John McFall 2005-03-10 Signed Dumbarton Labour Co-operative Peter Pike 2005-03-14 Signed Burnley Labour David Amess 2005-03-14 Signed Southend West Conservative Mike Hancock Withdrawn