36133 2007-08 1697A1 Jim McGovern 2008-06-17 leave out from `consequence' to end and insert `but is deeply concerned that in Scotland, where there are greater costs due to a higher proportion of rural geography and where life expectancy is lower than in England, the SNP minority administration is proposing in its budgets for the fiscal years 2008-09, 2009-10 and 2010-11 a significantly slower rate of increase in health spending than that proposed for England and Wales and that the current additional spend per head on health in Scotland over that in the rest of the United Kingdom will be dramatically reduced from £205 last year to £74 in 2010-11; and calls upon the Secretary of State for Scotland, when he next meets the First Minister, to challenge him on his administration's failure to support and properly invest in a first class healthcare system for Scotland.'. James McGovern 2008-06-17 Proposed Dundee West Labour David Hamilton 2008-06-17 Seconded Midlothian Labour Anne Begg 2008-06-17 Seconded Aberdeen South Labour Anne Moffat 2008-06-17 Seconded East Lothian Labour Jim Sheridan 2008-06-17 Seconded Paisley & Renfrewshire North Labour Jim Devine 2008-06-17 Signed Livingston Labour Frank Doran 2008-06-17 Signed Aberdeen North Labour Brian H Donohoe 2008-06-17 Signed Ayrshire Central Labour Ian Davidson 2008-06-17 Signed Glasgow South West Labour Michael Connarty 2008-06-17 Signed Linlithgow & Falkirk East Labour Tom Clarke 2008-06-17 Signed Coatbridge, Chryston & Bellshill Labour Sandra Osborne 2008-06-17 Signed Ayr, Carrick & Cumnock Labour Mohammad Sarwar 2008-06-17 Signed Glasgow Central Labour Nigel Griffiths 2008-06-17 Signed Edinburgh South Labour Ann McKechin Withdrawn