Parliament Website

Defence Of Provocation

EDM number 1240 in 1990-91, proposed by Jo Richardson on 14/10/1991.

That this House believes that the present case law on provocation discriminates against victims of domestic violence, resulting in wide and unacceptable variations in sentences; regards the case law criterion of 'sudden and temporary' loss of control as too restrictive because it prevents consideration of the effect of cumulative domestic violence; and calls for legislation to enable juries to take account of cumulative provocation and to provide that any consequent loss of control does not have to be sudden.

This motion has been signed by a total of 33 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Jo Richardson14/10/1991BarkingProposed
Archy Kirkwood14/10/1991Roxburgh & BerwickshireSigned
Nicholas Winterton14/10/1991MacclesfieldSigned
Jimmy Dunnachie15/10/1991Glasgow, PollokSigned
John Battle15/10/1991Leeds WestSigned
Harry Barnes15/10/1991North East DerbyshireSigned
Andrew Faulds15/10/1991Warley EastSigned
Lawrence Cunliffe15/10/1991LeighSigned
Ray Michie15/10/1991Argyll & ButeSigned
William McKelvey15/10/1991Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Ian McCartney15/10/1991MakerfieldSigned
Alice Mahon15/10/1991HalifaxSigned
Peter Hardy15/10/1991WentworthSigned
Ernie Ross15/10/1991Dundee WestSigned
John Home Robertson16/10/1991East LothianSigned
Gerry Steinberg16/10/1991Durham, City ofSigned
Roy Beggs16/10/1991East AntrimSigned
Win Griffiths16/10/1991BridgendSigned
John Evans16/10/1991St Helens NorthSigned
Frank Cook16/10/1991Stockton NorthSigned
Harry Cohen16/10/1991LeytonSigned
Keith Bradley16/10/1991Manchester, WithingtonSigned
Chris Mullin16/10/1991Sunderland SouthSigned
Alan Meale16/10/1991MansfieldSigned
John McAllion16/10/1991Dundee EastSigned
David Knox16/10/1991Staffordshire MoorlandsSigned
Sylvia Heal16/10/1991Staffordshire MidSigned
Dawn Primarolo16/10/1991Bristol SouthSigned
Eric Illsley17/10/1991Barnsley CentralSigned
Tony Lloyd17/10/1991StretfordSigned
Ronnie Campbell17/10/1991Blyth ValleySigned
Tom Cox17/10/1991TootingSigned
Jack Thompson21/10/1991WansbeckSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.