Parliament Website

Open Heart Surgery In South Wales And Conduct Of The Hon Member For Pembroke

EDM number 751 in 1990-91, proposed by Rhodri Morgan on 24/04/1991.

That this House notes with deep concern the parliamentary answer of the honourable Member for Pembroke to the honourable Member for Gower of 18th March, Official Report, column 4, regarding the number of open heart surgery operations in Wales, during Welsh Question Time, alleging that no such operations had taken place in Wales before 1979; notes that subsequent research has confirmed that these operations began in Wales in 1956; and finds it alarming that the honourable Member for Pembroke, in his capacity as the Government Minister responsible for health matters in Wales, should get his answer wrong by 23 years, thereby raising the question of the factual basis on which the honourable Member makes his ministerial decisions on health in Wales.

This motion has been signed by a total of 32 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Rhodri Morgan24/04/1991Cardiff WestProposed
John Smith24/04/1991Vale of GlamorganSigned
Paul Murphy24/04/1991TorfaenSigned
Paul Flynn24/04/1991Newport WestSigned
Gareth Wardell24/04/1991GowerSigned
Alan Williams24/04/1991Swansea WestSigned
Dennis Skinner25/04/1991BolsoverSigned
Bob Cryer25/04/1991Bradford SouthSigned
Harry Barnes25/04/1991North East DerbyshireSigned
Terry Lewis26/04/1991WorsleySigned
Win Griffiths26/04/1991BridgendSigned
John McAllion29/04/1991Dundee EastSigned
Alan Wynne Williams29/04/1991CarmarthenSigned
Denzil Davies29/04/1991LlanelliSigned
John Cummings29/04/1991EasingtonSigned
William McKelvey29/04/1991Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Ken Livingstone29/04/1991Brent EastSigned
Peter Hardy29/04/1991WentworthSigned
Ernie Ross29/04/1991Dundee WestSigned
Martin Redmond29/04/1991Don ValleySigned
Robert Parry29/04/1991Liverpool, RiversideSigned
Keith Bradley30/04/1991Manchester, WithingtonSigned
Harry Cohen30/04/1991LeytonSigned
John Evans30/04/1991St Helens NorthSigned
Harry Ewing30/04/1991Falkirk EastSigned
David Clelland01/05/1991Tyne BridgeSigned
Alexander Eadie01/05/1991MidlothianSigned
Jack Thompson01/05/1991WansbeckSigned
Martyn Jones03/05/1991Clwyd South WestSigned
Jeff Rooker07/05/1991Birmingham, Perry BarrSigned
Peter Pike15/05/1991BurnleySigned
Tommy Graham21/05/1991Renfrew West and InverclydeSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.