Parliament Website

Nhs Treatment

EDM number 568 in 1995-96, proposed by Harry Barnes on 05/03/1996.

That this House notes with grave concern that the principle of free health care on demand is being severely undermined by the lengthy periods which people have to wait for NHS treatment, compared to the speed with which private treatment can be arranged and that this places unfair pressures on many people who can ill-afford such fast-track treatment; believes that this is illustrated by the case of 11 year-old Daniel Eden of Wingerworth, whose severe headaches and sinuses kept him away from school for a considerable period, at a crucial stage in his academic development, and whose parents faced an invidious choice in either waiting many months for treatment, while their son suffered and remained away from school, or paying to have almost immediate private treatment; strongly condemns the Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department of Health whose response to representations from the honourable Member for North East Derbyshire was that Daniel's parents, rather than the health authorities, should have used avenues to chase up more rapid health treatment; and further condemns the anodyne statement from the Minister that it is for the individual to decide whether or not to seek private health care, as revealing that he is completely out of touch with the real world in which the prospect of months of delay forces many people, who have funded the NHS through their taxes, to pay twice for treatment.

This motion has been signed by a total of 39 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Harry Barnes05/03/1996North East DerbyshireProposed
Dennis Skinner05/03/1996BolsoverSigned
Tony Benn05/03/1996ChesterfieldSigned
Jean Corston06/03/1996Bristol EastSigned
Robert Wareing06/03/1996Liverpool, West DerbySigned
Paddy Tipping06/03/1996SherwoodSigned
Gerry Steinberg06/03/1996Durham, City ofSigned
Mike Hall06/03/1996Warrington SouthSigned
Paul Flynn06/03/1996Newport WestSigned
John Evans06/03/1996St Helens NorthSigned
Terry Davis06/03/1996Birmingham, Hodge HillSigned
John Cummings06/03/1996EasingtonSigned
Bill Michie06/03/1996Sheffield, HeeleySigned
William McKelvey06/03/1996Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Lynne Jones06/03/1996Birmingham, Selly OakSigned
Peter Hardy06/03/1996WentworthSigned
Ernie Ross06/03/1996Dundee WestSigned
Robert Parry06/03/1996Liverpool, RiversideSigned
Colin Pickthall06/03/1996West LancashireSigned
Bill Etherington07/03/1996Sunderland NorthSigned
Hugh Bayley07/03/1996York, City ofSigned
Neil Gerrard07/03/1996WalthamstowSigned
Rachel Squire08/03/1996Dunfermline WestSigned
Ken Livingstone08/03/1996Brent EastSigned
Tony Banks11/03/1996Newham North WestSigned
John Heppell12/03/1996Nottingham EastSigned
Martyn Jones12/03/1996Clwyd South WestSigned
Eddie Loyden12/03/1996Liverpool, GarstonSigned
Michael Clapham12/03/1996Barnsley West & PenistoneSigned
Mike Gapes12/03/1996Ilford SouthSigned
Martin Redmond18/03/1996Don ValleySigned
Gordon Prentice19/03/1996PendleSigned
Angela Eagle21/03/1996WallaseySigned
Terry Rooney17/04/1996Bradford NorthSigned
David Clelland18/04/1996Tyne BridgeSigned
Anne Campbell24/04/1996CambridgeSigned
Diane Abbott25/04/1996Hackney North & Stoke NewingtonSigned
Dale Campbell-Savours02/05/1996WorkingtonSigned
Nigel Jones21/05/1996CheltenhamSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.