Audit Commission Report On Gp Fundholding
EDM number 927 in 1995-96, proposed by Hugh Bayley on 22/05/1996.
That this House welcomes the Audit Commission's report What The Doctor Ordered; notes that this is the first objective analysis of the effectiveness of general practitioner fundholding; expresses concern at the Audit Commission's conclusion that the administrative cost of fundholding is greater than savings it had achieved for improving patient care; expresses concern at the finding that few fundholders are using clinical audit and patient outcome information to target their health spending on treatments which work; recalls the Health Committee's concern about the lack of accountability of general practitioner fundholders and its recommendation that fundholders should be required to sign up to a local health strategy agreed with their health authority before gaining access to their budget; welcomes the Audit Commission's proposal for improving the accountability framework for fundholding and its recommendation that fundholders should take account of their health authority's local health priorities in their plans; recognises that general practitioner-led local commissioning, involving fundholding and non-fundholding general practitioners, is addressing these problems and appears to be delivering clinically effective and cost-effective treatment for patients; calls upon the Department of Health to fund independent research into the effectiveness of general practitioner commissioning; and calls upon the Leader of the House to schedule a debate on the Audit Commissioner's Report on general practitioner fundholding in Government time.
This motion has been signed by a total of 65 MPs.
| MP | Date | Constituency | Party | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hugh Bayley | 22/05/1996 | York, City of | Proposed | |
| Gordon Prentice | 22/05/1996 | Pendle | Signed | |
| Tony Worthington | 22/05/1996 | Clydebank & Milngavie | Signed | |
| Audrey Wise | 22/05/1996 | Preston | Signed | |
| Tony Banks | 22/05/1996 | Newham North West | Signed | |
| John Gunnell | 22/05/1996 | Leeds South and Morley | Signed | |
| Neil Gerrard | 22/05/1996 | Walthamstow | Signed | |
| Paul Flynn | 22/05/1996 | Newport West | Signed | |
| Angela Eagle | 22/05/1996 | Wallasey | Signed | |
| Ian Davidson | 22/05/1996 | Glasgow, Govan | Signed | |
| Ann Clwyd | 22/05/1996 | Cynon Valley | Signed | |
| Michael Clapham | 22/05/1996 | Barnsley West & Penistone | Signed | |
| Judith Church | 22/05/1996 | Dagenham | Signed | |
| Malcolm Chisholm | 22/05/1996 | Edinburgh Leith | Signed | |
| Rhodri Morgan | 22/05/1996 | Cardiff West | Signed | |
| Alice Mahon | 22/05/1996 | Halifax | Signed | |
| Brian Sedgemore | 22/05/1996 | Hackney South & Shoreditch | Signed | |
| Barry Sheerman | 22/05/1996 | Huddersfield | Signed | |
| Alan Simpson | 22/05/1996 | Nottingham South | Signed | |
| John Spellar | 22/05/1996 | Warley West | Signed | |
| Peter Hardy | 22/05/1996 | Wentworth | Signed | |
| Keith Hill | 22/05/1996 | Streatham | Signed | |
| Kevin Hughes | 22/05/1996 | Doncaster North | Signed | |
| David Jamieson | 22/05/1996 | Plymouth, Devonport | Signed | |
| Lynne Jones | 22/05/1996 | Birmingham, Selly Oak | Signed | |
| Alan Keen | 22/05/1996 | Feltham & Heston | Signed | |
| Denis MacShane | 22/05/1996 | Rotherham | Signed | |
| Andrew Miller | 22/05/1996 | Ellesmere Port & Neston | Signed | |
| Ernie Ross | 04/06/1996 | Dundee West | Signed | |
| John Heppell | 04/06/1996 | Nottingham East | Signed | |
| Ken Livingstone | 04/06/1996 | Brent East | Signed | |
| William McKelvey | 04/06/1996 | Kilmarnock & Loudoun | Signed | |
| Dennis Skinner | 05/06/1996 | Bolsover | Signed | |
| Joan Walley | 05/06/1996 | Stoke-on-Trent North | Signed | |
| Gerry Steinberg | 05/06/1996 | Durham, City of | Signed | |
| Harry Barnes | 05/06/1996 | North East Derbyshire | Signed | |
| Mike Hall | 05/06/1996 | Warrington South | Signed | |
| Norman Godman | 05/06/1996 | Greenock and Port Glasgow | Signed | |
| Kenneth Eastham | 05/06/1996 | Manchester, Blackley | Signed | |
| Jean Corston | 05/06/1996 | Bristol East | Signed | |
| Keith Bradley | 05/06/1996 | Manchester, Withington | Signed | |
| Bill Michie | 05/06/1996 | Sheffield, Heeley | Signed | |
| Eddie Loyden | 05/06/1996 | Liverpool, Garston | Signed | |
| John Evans | 05/06/1996 | St Helens North | Signed | |
| Anne Campbell | 06/06/1996 | Cambridge | Signed | |
| Maria Fyfe | 06/06/1996 | Glasgow, Maryhill | Signed | |
| Diane Abbott | 06/06/1996 | Hackney North & Stoke Newington | Signed | |
| Glenda Jackson | 07/06/1996 | Hampstead & Highgate | Signed | |
| Martin Redmond | 10/06/1996 | Don Valley | Signed | |
| Robert Wareing | 10/06/1996 | Liverpool, West Derby | Signed | |
| Richard Burden | 11/06/1996 | Birmingham, Northfield | Signed | |
| Jack Thompson | 11/06/1996 | Wansbeck | Signed | |
| Eric Illsley | 11/06/1996 | Barnsley Central | Signed | |
| Max Madden | 12/06/1996 | Bradford West | Signed | |
| Mike Gapes | 12/06/1996 | Ilford South | Signed | |
| Win Griffiths | 12/06/1996 | Bridgend | Signed | |
| Elfyn Llwyd | 18/06/1996 | Meirionnydd Nant Conwy | Signed | |
| Bill Etherington | 18/06/1996 | Sunderland North | Signed | |
| Dafydd Wigley | 18/06/1996 | Caernarfon | Signed | |
| Rachel Squire | 19/06/1996 | Dunfermline West | Signed | |
| Terry Davis | 19/06/1996 | Birmingham, Hodge Hill | Signed | |
| Peter Pike | 24/06/1996 | Burnley | Signed | |
| Gerry Sutcliffe | 04/07/1996 | Bradford South | Signed | |
| Tommy Graham | 18/07/1996 | Renfrew West and Inverclyde | Signed | |
| Tony Lloyd | 24/07/1996 | Stretford | Signed |
Download raw data as csv or xml.

