Compensation For Injured Grenadiers
EDM number 776 in 1990-91, proposed by Ray Powell on 30/04/1991.
That this House, conscious of the fact that real care for the men and women of our armed forces has enabled our country to rely, even to the point of ultimate sacrifice, upon their loyalty, steadfastness and efficiency in times of grave national threat, is astounded to note that, when digging a trench during an official Army exercise in Canada in July 1989, three men of the Grenadier Guards (Adrian Hicks, John Ray and Sean Povey) detonated a six year old unexploded shell which not only rendered them limbless but caused them such grievous wounds that Guardsman Ray and Guardsman Povey are still, after almost two years, in receipt of hospital treatment; notes that the Ministry of Defence find themselves unable, on the grounds of unattributable negligence, to pay compensation; and calls upon the Prime Minister to review this case personally and to ensure that, regardless of the possible legal responsibility of some unknown nation who failed to `clear' the shell some six years previously, Her Majesty's Government is seen to follow truly a policy that shows an appreciation of human understanding, human dignity and the value of a human life on earth by awarding generous compensation and a return of the accumulated legal costs to these youthful British Grenadiers.
This motion has been signed by a total of 164 MPs.
MP | Date | Constituency | Party | Type |
Raymond Powell | 01/05/1991 | Ogmore | | Proposed |
Marion Roe | 01/05/1991 | Broxbourne | | Signed |
David Shaw | 01/05/1991 | Dover | | Signed |
Tim Smith | 01/05/1991 | Beaconsfield | | Signed |
Ralph Howell | 01/05/1991 | North Norfolk | | Signed |
Andrew Hunter | 01/05/1991 | Basingstoke | | Signed |
Russell Johnston | 01/05/1991 | Inverness, Nairn and Lochaber | | Signed |
James Kilfedder | 01/05/1991 | North Down | | Signed |
Ivan Lawrence | 01/05/1991 | Burton | | Signed |
Roger Moate | 01/05/1991 | Faversham | | Signed |
Emma Nicholson | 01/05/1991 | Torridge & West Devon | | Signed |
Rhodes Boyson | 01/05/1991 | Brent North | | Signed |
Alex Carlile | 01/05/1991 | Montgomery | | Signed |
Winston Churchill | 01/05/1991 | Davyhulme | | Signed |
Sam Galbraith | 01/05/1991 | Strathkelvin & Bearsden | | Signed |
Bruce George | 01/05/1991 | Walsall South | | Signed |
John Hannam | 01/05/1991 | Exeter | | Signed |
Jack Aspinwall | 01/05/1991 | Wansdyke | | Signed |
Tony Banks | 01/05/1991 | Newham North West | | Signed |
Henry Bellingham | 01/05/1991 | North West Norfolk | | Signed |
Gerard Vaughan | 01/05/1991 | Reading East | | Signed |
John Wilkinson | 01/05/1991 | Ruislip - Northwood | | Signed |
Ann Winterton | 01/05/1991 | Congleton | | Signed |
David Knox | 02/05/1991 | Staffordshire Moorlands | | Signed |
Nicholas Winterton | 02/05/1991 | Macclesfield | | Signed |
Peter Hardy | 07/05/1991 | Wentworth | | Signed |
Michael Mates | 07/05/1991 | East Hampshire | | Signed |
Michael Morris | 07/05/1991 | Northampton South | | Signed |
David Winnick | 07/05/1991 | Walsall North | | Signed |
Ian Grist | 08/05/1991 | Cardiff Central | | Signed |
John Battle | 08/05/1991 | Leeds West | | Signed |
Willie Ross | 09/05/1991 | East Londonderry | | Signed |
Alan Meale | 09/05/1991 | Mansfield | | Signed |
Edward O'Hara | 09/05/1991 | Knowsley South | | Signed |
Michael Colvin | 09/05/1991 | Romsey and Waterside | | Signed |
Ronnie Fearn | 09/05/1991 | Southport | | Signed |
Roy Beggs | 09/05/1991 | East Antrim | | Signed |
John Taylor | 09/05/1991 | Strangford | | Signed |
Jack Thompson | 10/05/1991 | Wansbeck | | Signed |
Jim Wallace | 13/05/1991 | Orkney & Shetland | | Signed |
Anthony Meyer | 15/05/1991 | Clwyd North West | | Signed |
James Pawsey | 15/05/1991 | Rugby & Kenilworth | | Signed |
Giles Radice | 15/05/1991 | North Durham | | Signed |
Timothy Raison | 15/05/1991 | Aylesbury | | Signed |
Jim Sillars | 15/05/1991 | Glasgow, Govan | | Signed |
Roger Sims | 15/05/1991 | Chislehurst | | Signed |
James Hill | 15/05/1991 | Southampton, Test | | Signed |
David Howell | 15/05/1991 | Guildford | | Signed |
Geraint Howells | 15/05/1991 | Ceredigion and Pembroke North | | Signed |
Greville Janner | 15/05/1991 | Leicester West | | Signed |
Jill Knight | 15/05/1991 | Birmingham, Edgbaston | | Signed |
Terry Lewis | 15/05/1991 | Worsley | | Signed |
Paul Marland | 15/05/1991 | Gloucestershire West | | Signed |
David Marshall | 15/05/1991 | Glasgow, Shettleston | | Signed |
Michael Martin | 15/05/1991 | Glasgow, Springburn | | Signed |
Gordon Oakes | 15/05/1991 | Halton | | Signed |
Bill Cash | 15/05/1991 | Stafford | | Signed |
Derek Conway | 15/05/1991 | Shrewsbury & Atcham | | Signed |
James Couchman | 15/05/1991 | Gillingham | | Signed |
Edwina Currie | 15/05/1991 | South Derbyshire | | Signed |
Geoffrey Dickens | 15/05/1991 | Littleborough and Saddleworth | | Signed |
Dick Douglas | 15/05/1991 | Dunfermline West | | Signed |
Den Dover | 15/05/1991 | Chorley | | Signed |
Jimmy Dunnachie | 15/05/1991 | Glasgow, Pollok | | Signed |
Margaret Ewing | 15/05/1991 | Moray | | Signed |
Nicholas Fairbairn | 15/05/1991 | Perth and Kinross | | Signed |
George Foulkes | 15/05/1991 | Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley | | Signed |
Marcus Fox | 15/05/1991 | Shipley | | Signed |
George Gardiner | 15/05/1991 | Reigate | | Signed |
Christopher Gill | 15/05/1991 | Ludlow | | Signed |
Norman Godman | 15/05/1991 | Greenock and Port Glasgow | | Signed |
Teresa Gorman | 15/05/1991 | Billericay | | Signed |
Harry Greenway | 15/05/1991 | Ealing North | | Signed |
Jonathan Aitken | 15/05/1991 | South Thanet | | Signed |
Michael Grylls | 15/05/1991 | Surrey North West | | Signed |
Jacques Arnold | 15/05/1991 | Gravesham | | Signed |
Spencer Batiste | 15/05/1991 | Elmet | | Signed |
Vivian Bendall | 15/05/1991 | Ilford North | | Signed |
Richard Body | 15/05/1991 | Holland with Boston | | Signed |
Andrew Bowden | 15/05/1991 | Brighton, Kemptown | | Signed |
Peter Temple-Morris | 15/05/1991 | Leominster | | Signed |
Neville Trotter | 15/05/1991 | Tynemouth | | Signed |
George Walden | 15/05/1991 | Buckingham | | Signed |
Bill Walker | 15/05/1991 | North Tayside | | Signed |
John Ward | 15/05/1991 | Poole | | Signed |
John Watts | 15/05/1991 | Slough | | Signed |
Bowen Wells | 15/05/1991 | Hertford & Stortford | | Signed |
Mark Wolfson | 15/05/1991 | Sevenoaks | | Signed |
James Wray | 15/05/1991 | Glasgow Provan | | Signed |
Elizabeth Peacock | 16/05/1991 | Batley & Spen | | Signed |
Barry Porter | 16/05/1991 | Wirral South | | Signed |
William Powell | 16/05/1991 | Corby | | Signed |
Tim Rathbone | 16/05/1991 | Lewes | | Signed |
Ernie Ross | 16/05/1991 | Dundee West | | Signed |
Brian Sedgemore | 16/05/1991 | Hackney South & Shoreditch | | Signed |
Peter Shore | 16/05/1991 | Bethnal Green and Stepney | | Signed |
Trevor Skeet | 16/05/1991 | Bedfordshire North | | Signed |
Dudley Smith | 16/05/1991 | Warwick & Leamington | | Signed |
Martin Smyth | 16/05/1991 | Belfast South | | Signed |
Nigel Spearing | 16/05/1991 | Newham South | | Signed |
Keith Speed | 16/05/1991 | Ashford | | Signed |
Michael Spicer | 16/05/1991 | Worcestershire South | | Signed |
Alan Haselhurst | 16/05/1991 | Saffron Walden | | Signed |
Jerry Hayes | 16/05/1991 | Harlow | | Signed |
Robert Hicks | 16/05/1991 | South East Cornwall | | Signed |
Robert Hughes | 16/05/1991 | Aberdeen North | | Signed |
Simon Hughes | 16/05/1991 | Southwark and Bermondsey | | Signed |
John Hunt | 16/05/1991 | Ravensbourne | | Signed |
Adam Ingram | 16/05/1991 | East Kilbride | | Signed |
Ken Livingstone | 16/05/1991 | Brent East | | Signed |
Richard Luce | 16/05/1991 | Shoreham | | Signed |
Ken Maginnis | 16/05/1991 | Fermanagh & South Tyrone | | Signed |
John McAllion | 16/05/1991 | Dundee East | | Signed |
Thomas McAvoy | 16/05/1991 | Glasgow, Rutherglen | | Signed |
William McKelvey | 16/05/1991 | Kilmarnock & Loudoun | | Signed |
Henry McLeish | 16/05/1991 | Central Fife | | Signed |
Iain Mills | 16/05/1991 | Meriden | | Signed |
Austin Mitchell | 16/05/1991 | Great Grimsby | | Signed |
James Molyneaux | 16/05/1991 | Lagan Valley | | Signed |
Chris Mullin | 16/05/1991 | Sunderland South | | Signed |
Anthony Nelson | 16/05/1991 | Chichester | | Signed |
Ian Paisley | 16/05/1991 | North Antrim | | Signed |
Ronald Brown | 16/05/1991 | Edinburgh Leith | | Signed |
Alistair Burt | 16/05/1991 | Bury North | | Signed |
John Butcher | 16/05/1991 | Coventry South West | | Signed |
John Carlisle | 16/05/1991 | Luton North | | Signed |
Harry Cohen | 16/05/1991 | Leyton | | Signed |
Jeremy Corbyn | 16/05/1991 | Islington North | | Signed |
Tom Cox | 16/05/1991 | Tooting | | Signed |
James Cran | 16/05/1991 | Beverley | | Signed |
Alistair Darling | 16/05/1991 | Edinburgh Central | | Signed |
Alexander Eadie | 16/05/1991 | Midlothian | | Signed |
David Evennett | 16/05/1991 | Erith and Crayford | | Signed |
Clifford Forsythe | 16/05/1991 | South Antrim | | Signed |
Douglas French | 16/05/1991 | Gloucester | | Signed |
Peter Fry | 16/05/1991 | Wellingborough | | Signed |
Roger Gale | 16/05/1991 | North Thanet | | Signed |
John Garrett | 16/05/1991 | Norwich South | | Signed |
Mildred Gordon | 16/05/1991 | Bow and Poplar | | Signed |
John Gorst | 16/05/1991 | Hendon North | | Signed |
Anthony Grant | 16/05/1991 | Cambridge South West | | Signed |
Richard Alexander | 16/05/1991 | Newark | | Signed |
Michael Alison | 16/05/1991 | Selby | | Signed |
Rupert Allason | 16/05/1991 | Torbay | | Signed |
Keith Hampson | 16/05/1991 | Leeds North West | | Signed |
David Ashby | 16/05/1991 | North West Leicestershire | | Signed |
Joe Ashton | 16/05/1991 | Bassetlaw | | Signed |
Robert Banks | 16/05/1991 | Harrogate | | Signed |
Alan Beith | 16/05/1991 | Berwick-upon-Tweed | | Signed |
Stuart Bell | 16/05/1991 | Middlesbrough | | Signed |
John Blackburn | 16/05/1991 | Dudley West | | Signed |
Nicholas Bonsor | 16/05/1991 | Upminster | | Signed |
Teddy Taylor | 16/05/1991 | Southend East | | Signed |
Patrick Thompson | 16/05/1991 | Norwich North | | Signed |
Keith Vaz | 16/05/1991 | Leicester East | | Signed |
Gary Waller | 16/05/1991 | Keighley | | Signed |
John Wheeler | 16/05/1991 | Westminster North | | Signed |
Jerry Wiggin | 16/05/1991 | Weston-Super-Mare | | Signed |
Alan Williams | 16/05/1991 | Swansea West | | Signed |
George Younger | 16/05/1991 | Ayr | | Signed |
William McCrea | 16/05/1991 | Mid Ulster | | Signed |
Anthony Durant | 21/05/1991 | Reading West | | Signed |
Tommy Graham | 21/05/1991 | Renfrew West and Inverclyde | | Signed |
Win Griffiths | 22/05/1991 | Bridgend | | Signed |
Download raw data as
csv or
xml.