Parliament Website

Conduct Of Lord Butler Of Brockwell

EDM number 540 in 2003-04, proposed by Llew Smith on 03/02/2004.

That this House notes that Lord Butler of Brockwell, as Cabinet Secretary, told the Scott Inquiry when asked about the less than full information being provided in parliamentary answers, 'You have to be selective about the facts', and commented to the Scott Inquiry, on parliamentary answers, 'It was an accurate but incomplete answer. The purpose of it was to give an answer which itself was true. It did not give the full picture. It was half an answer'; and believes that this attitude shown by Lord Butler of Brockwell towards the importance of the provision of proper accurate information to Parliament undermines his credibility as a fair and impartial chairman for the Weapons of Mass Destruction Intelligence Inquiry.

This motion has been signed by a total of 28 MPs, 1 of these signatures have been withdrawn.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Llew Smith03/02/2004Blaenau GwentLabourProposed
Alan Simpson03/02/2004Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
Kelvin Hopkins03/02/2004Luton NorthLabourSigned
Glenda Jackson03/02/2004Hampstead & HighgateLabourSigned
Jon Owen Jones03/02/2004Cardiff CentralLabour Co-operativeSigned
Peter Kilfoyle03/02/2004Liverpool, WaltonLabourSigned
John McDonnell03/02/2004Hayes & HarlingtonLabourSigned
Harry Cohen03/02/2004Leyton & WansteadLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn03/02/2004Islington NorthLabourSigned
Diane Abbott03/02/2004Hackney North & Stoke NewingtonLabourSigned
Robert Wareing03/02/2004Liverpool, West DerbyLabourSigned
Paul Flynn04/02/2004Newport WestLabourSigned
Derek Wyatt04/02/2004Sittingbourne & SheppeyLabourSigned
Simon Thomas04/02/2004CeredigionPlaid CymruSigned
David Taylor04/02/2004North West LeicestershireLabour Co-operativeSigned
Frank Cook04/02/2004Stockton NorthLabourSigned
Alice Mahon04/02/2004HalifaxLabourSigned
Elfyn Llwyd04/02/2004Meirionnydd Nant ConwyPlaid CymruSigned
Kevin McNamara05/02/2004Kingston upon Hull NorthLabourSigned
Lynne Jones06/02/2004Birmingham, Selly OakLabourSigned
Harold Best06/02/2004Leeds North WestLabourSigned
Alistair Carmichael09/02/2004Orkney & ShetlandLiberal DemocratSigned
Jenny Tonge10/02/2004Richmond ParkLiberal DemocratSigned
Paul Holmes11/02/2004ChesterfieldLiberal DemocratSigned
Alex Salmond12/02/2004Banff & BuchanScottish National PartySigned
Terry Lewis12/02/2004WorsleyLabourSigned
Annabelle Ewing26/02/2004PerthScottish National PartySigned
Terry DavisUnknownWithdrawn

Download raw data as csv or xml.