Parliament Website

Disability Living Allowance Consultation

EDM number 1332 in 2010-12, proposed by Hywel Williams on 24/01/2011.
Categorised under the topic of Sickness, disability and carers' benefits.

That this House expresses concern at the presentation of the case for reform of Disability Living Allowance (DLA) in the public consultation published on 6 December 2010; believes that the consultation incorrectly confuses correlation with causation between DLA claimants and employment levels or motivation to work; notes that DLA claimants tend to be older, less well-qualified, on benefits for longer and in poorer health than other disabled people; is of the opinion that many of the claims made in support of changing DLA are unsubstantiated in the consultation text or the supporting evidence; does not accept the argument that the identified problems with the present format of DLA are insoluble without the introduction of a costly new benefit; further believes that the presentation of the case for these reforms is highly flawed; and further expresses concern that the language used in the consultation may mislead readers when drawing conclusions from the evidence presented, and may therefore influence their response to the consultation.

This motion has been signed by a total of 80 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Hywel Williams24/01/2011ArfonPlaid CymruProposed
Jonathan Edwards24/01/2011Carmarthen East and DinefwrPlaid CymruSeconded
Elfyn Llwyd24/01/2011Dwyfor MeirionnyddPlaid CymruSeconded
Mark Durkan25/01/2011FoyleSocial Democratic and Labour PartySeconded
William McCrea25/01/2011South AntrimDUPSeconded
Martin Caton25/01/2011GowerLabourSeconded
Jim Shannon25/01/2011StrangfordDUPSigned
Albert Owen25/01/2011Ynys MLabourSigned
Alex Cunningham25/01/2011Stockton NorthLabourSigned
Kate Green26/01/2011Stretford and UrmstonLabourSigned
Clive Betts26/01/2011Sheffield South EastLabourSigned
Mike Gapes26/01/2011Ilford SouthLabourSigned
Hywel Francis26/01/2011AberavonLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn26/01/2011Islington NorthLabourSigned
Ronnie Campbell26/01/2011Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
John McDonnell26/01/2011Hayes and HarlingtonLabourSigned
Lady Hermon26/01/2011North DownIndependentSigned
Mary Glindon27/01/2011North TynesideLabourSigned
Caroline Lucas27/01/2011Brighton, PavilionGreenSigned
Anne Begg27/01/2011Aberdeen SouthLabourSigned
Marsha Singh27/01/2011Bradford WestLabourSigned
Paul Flynn31/01/2011Newport WestLabourSigned
Michael Meacher31/01/2011Oldham West and RoytonLabourSigned
Alan Meale31/01/2011MansfieldLabourSigned
Kelvin Hopkins31/01/2011Luton NorthLabourSigned
Margaret Ritchie31/01/2011South DownSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Andrew Miller01/02/2011Ellesmere Port and NestonLabourSigned
Katy Clark01/02/2011North Ayrshire and ArranLabourSigned
Graeme Morrice02/02/2011LivingstonLabourSigned
Glenda Jackson02/02/2011Hampstead and KilburnLabourSigned
Naomi Long02/02/2011Belfast EastAllianceSigned
David Simpson02/02/2011Upper BannDUPSigned
Joan Walley03/02/2011Stoke-on-Trent NorthLabourSigned
Steve Rotheram03/02/2011Liverpool, WaltonLabourSigned
Alasdair McDonnell03/02/2011Belfast SouthSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Jenny Chapman04/02/2011DarlingtonLabourSigned
Tony Lloyd04/02/2011Manchester CentralLabourSigned
Jim Cunningham07/02/2011Coventry SouthLabourSigned
Tom Harris07/02/2011Glasgow SouthLabourSigned
John Robertson07/02/2011Glasgow North WestLabourSigned
Chris Ruane07/02/2011Vale of ClwydLabourSigned
Jim Sheridan08/02/2011Paisley and Renfrewshire NorthLabourSigned
Michael Connarty08/02/2011Linlithgow and East FalkirkLabourSigned
Ian Davidson08/02/2011Glasgow South WestLabourSigned
Sheila Gilmore08/02/2011Edinburgh EastLabourSigned
Barry Sheerman08/02/2011HuddersfieldLabourSigned
Joan Ruddock09/02/2011Lewisham, DeptfordLabourSigned
Jon Cruddas09/02/2011Dagenham and RainhamLabourSigned
Linda Riordan10/02/2011HalifaxLabourSigned
Nigel Dodds10/02/2011Belfast NorthDUPSigned
David Crausby10/02/2011Bolton North EastLabourSigned
Gerald Kaufman11/02/2011Manchester, GortonLabourSigned
Mike Wood11/02/2011Batley and SpenLabourSigned
Alun Michael14/02/2011Cardiff South and PenarthLabourSigned
David Blunkett14/02/2011Sheffield, Brightside and HillsboroughLabourSigned
Eilidh Whiteford14/02/2011Banff and BuchanScottish National PartySigned
Valerie Vaz14/02/2011Walsall SouthLabourSigned
Debbie Abrahams15/02/2011Oldham East and SaddleworthLabourSigned
Pamela Nash15/02/2011Airdrie and ShottsLabourSigned
Michael Weir15/02/2011AngusScottish National PartySigned
Stewart Hosie15/02/2011Dundee EastScottish National PartySigned
Hugh Bayley16/02/2011York CentralLabourSigned
David Cairns17/02/2011InverclydeLabourSigned
Tony Cunningham28/02/2011WorkingtonLabourSigned
Heidi Alexander28/02/2011Lewisham EastLabourSigned
Alison McGovern28/02/2011Wirral SouthLabourSigned
Clive Efford02/03/2011ElthamLabourSigned
Dave Watts02/03/2011St Helens NorthLabourSigned
Kevin Barron03/03/2011Rother ValleyLabourSigned
Dai Havard08/03/2011Merthyr Tydfil and RhymneyLabourSigned
Yvonne Fovargue08/03/2011MakerfieldLabourSigned
Roger Godsiff08/03/2011Birmingham, Hall GreenLabourSigned
Gregory Campbell09/03/2011East LondonderryDUPSigned
Joe Benton15/03/2011BootleLabourSigned
Lindsay Roy16/03/2011GlenrothesLabourSigned
Kate Hoey24/03/2011VauxhallLabourSigned
Paul Blomfield24/03/2011Sheffield CentralLabourSigned
Grahame Morris24/03/2011EasingtonLabourSigned
Geoffrey Robinson16/05/2011Coventry North WestLabourSigned
Chris Evans19/05/2011IslwynLabourSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.