Parliament Website

NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE'S FINAL DECISION ON ALZHEIMER'S DRUGS

EDM number 2323 in 2005-06, proposed by Roger Berry on 07/06/2006.

That this House is deeply concerned by the final decision of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) on drugs for Alzheimer's disease, which restricts access to NHS treatment to people in the moderate stages of the disease; believes that Alzheimer's drugs are clinically and cost-effective; notes that the drug treatments cost only £2.50 per person per day; is concerned that clinicians will be prevented from prescribing effective drugs to thousands of people in the early and late stages of dementia; is deeply concerned that prohibiting Ebixa on the NHS, the only treatment available for people in the later stages, will lead to an increase in the prescription of dangerous sedative drugs; further believes people with dementia should be entitled to good quality care and access to effective drug treatments; further believes that this decision contradicts Government policy on early intervention, support for carers and maintaining independence; supports the appeal by members of the Action on Alzheimer's Drugs Alliance to NICE to overturn this damaging decision; further notes that the Department of Health has raised serious concerns about the way NICE has calculated the cost-effectiveness of these drugs; further believes that the Department of Health has a duty to hold NICE to account in circumstances where there are flaws in NICE's appraisal process; and calls upon the Government to consider seriously how people in the early and later stages of Alzheimer's disease can continue to have access to treatment.

This motion has been signed by a total of 118 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Roger Berry07/06/2006KingswoodLabourProposed
Peter Bottomley07/06/2006Worthing WestConservativeSeconded
Martin Horwood07/06/2006CheltenhamLiberal DemocratSeconded
Richard Taylor07/06/2006Wyre ForestIndependentSeconded
Desmond Turner07/06/2006Brighton, KemptownLabourSeconded
Michael Penning08/06/2006Hemel HempsteadConservativeSeconded
Gordon Prentice08/06/2006PendleLabourSigned
John Pugh08/06/2006SouthportLiberal DemocratSigned
Bob Spink08/06/2006Castle PointConservativeSigned
Paul Holmes08/06/2006ChesterfieldLiberal DemocratSigned
Lindsay Hoyle08/06/2006ChorleyLabourSigned
Brian Jenkins08/06/2006TamworthLabourSigned
Alan Meale08/06/2006MansfieldLabourSigned
Annette Brooke08/06/2006Mid Dorset and North PooleLiberal DemocratSigned
Richard Burden08/06/2006Birmingham, NorthfieldLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn08/06/2006Islington NorthLabourSigned
Janet Dean08/06/2006BurtonLabourSigned
Andrew Dismore08/06/2006HendonLabourSigned
Andrew George08/06/2006St IvesLiberal DemocratSigned
Ian Gibson08/06/2006Norwich NorthLabourSigned
Graham Stringer08/06/2006Manchester, BlackleyLabourSigned
Paddy Tipping08/06/2006SherwoodLabourSigned
Nicholas Winterton08/06/2006MacclesfieldConservativeSigned
David Lepper12/06/2006Brighton, PavilionLabourSigned
Gordon Marsden12/06/2006Blackpool SouthLabourSigned
Chris McCafferty12/06/2006Calder ValleyLabourSigned
John Cummings12/06/2006EasingtonLabourSigned
Hywel Francis12/06/2006AberavonLabourSigned
Mike Hancock12/06/2006Portsmouth SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
David Taylor12/06/2006North West LeicestershireLabourSigned
Helen Goodman12/06/2006Bishop AucklandLabourSigned
Bob Russell13/06/2006ColchesterLiberal DemocratSigned
Kelvin Hopkins13/06/2006Luton NorthLabourSigned
Glenda Jackson13/06/2006Hampstead and HighgateLabourSigned
Fraser Kemp13/06/2006Houghton and Washington EastLabourSigned
William McCrea13/06/2006South AntrimDUPSigned
Colin Breed13/06/2006South East CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Martin Caton13/06/2006GowerLabourSigned
David Clelland13/06/2006Tyne BridgeLabourSigned
Derek Conway13/06/2006Old Bexley & SidcupConservativeSigned
Jim Dobbin13/06/2006Heywood and MiddletonLabourSigned
Jeffrey M Donaldson13/06/2006Lagan ValleyDUPSigned
David Drew13/06/2006StroudLabourSigned
John Leech13/06/2006Manchester, WithingtonLiberal DemocratSigned
Angus MacNeil13/06/2006Na h-Eileanan an IarScottish National PartySigned
Madeleine Moon13/06/2006BridgendLabourSigned
Mark Hunter13/06/2006CheadleLiberal DemocratSigned
Julie Morgan14/06/2006Cardiff NorthLabourSigned
Joan Ruddock14/06/2006Lewisham, DeptfordLabourSigned
Joan Humble14/06/2006Blackpool North and FleetwoodLabourSigned
Elfyn Llwyd14/06/2006Meirionnydd Nant ConwyPlaid CymruSigned
Rob Marris14/06/2006Wolverhampton South WestLabourSigned
Doug Naysmith14/06/2006Bristol North WestLabourSigned
Gregory Campbell14/06/2006East LondonderryDUPSigned
Ronnie Campbell14/06/2006Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
Michael Clapham14/06/2006Barnsley West and PenistoneLabourSigned
Paul Flynn14/06/2006Newport WestLabourSigned
James Gray14/06/2006North WiltshireConservativeSigned
Betty Williams14/06/2006ConwyLabourSigned
Phil Willis14/06/2006Harrogate and KnaresboroughLiberal DemocratSigned
Jeremy Browne14/06/2006TauntonLiberal DemocratSigned
Stephen Williams14/06/2006Bristol WestLiberal DemocratSigned
Alasdair McDonnell15/06/2006Belfast SouthSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Jeff Ennis15/06/2006Barnsley East and MexboroughLabourSigned
Robert Wareing15/06/2006Liverpool, West DerbyLabourSigned
Roger Williams15/06/2006Brecon and RadnorshireLiberal DemocratSigned
Judy Mallaber16/06/2006Amber ValleyLabourSigned
Vincent Cable19/06/2006TwickenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
Dai Havard20/06/2006Merthyr Tydfil and RhymneyLabourSigned
Lady Hermon20/06/2006North DownUUPSigned
Denis Murphy20/06/2006WansbeckLabourSigned
Edward O'Hara20/06/2006Knowsley SouthLabourSigned
David Crausby20/06/2006Bolton North EastLabourSigned
Ann Cryer20/06/2006KeighleyLabourSigned
Nigel Dodds20/06/2006Belfast NorthDUPSigned
Dan Rogerson20/06/2006North CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Mark Williams20/06/2006CeredigionLiberal DemocratSigned
Iris Robinson21/06/2006StrangfordDUPSigned
David Heyes21/06/2006Ashton-under-LyneLabourSigned
James Clappison21/06/2006HertsmereConservativeSigned
Jeremy Wright21/06/2006Rugby and KenilworthConservativeSigned
Neil Gerrard22/06/2006WalthamstowLabourSigned
Janet Anderson22/06/2006Rossendale and DarwenLabourSigned
Rudi Vis22/06/2006Finchley and Golders GreenLabourSigned
John Hemming22/06/2006Birmingham, YardleyLiberal DemocratSigned
Alan Simpson27/06/2006Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
John McDonnell27/06/2006Hayes and HarlingtonLabourSigned
David Borrow27/06/2006South RibbleLabourSigned
Matthew Taylor27/06/2006Truro and St AustellLiberal DemocratSigned
Richard Younger-Ross27/06/2006TeignbridgeLiberal DemocratSigned
David Simpson28/06/2006Upper BannDUPSigned
David Amess28/06/2006Southend WestConservativeSigned
Philip Dunne28/06/2006LudlowConservativeSigned
Eric Illsley29/06/2006Barnsley CentralLabourSigned
Laura Moffatt29/06/2006CrawleyLabourSigned
John Bercow29/06/2006BuckinghamConservativeSigned
Mike Gapes03/07/2006Ilford SouthLabourSigned
Paul Rowen03/07/2006RochdaleLiberal DemocratSigned
Geoffrey Robinson04/07/2006Coventry North WestLabourSigned
Grant Shapps04/07/2006Welwyn HatfieldConservativeSigned
Gwyn Prosser06/07/2006DoverLabourSigned
Geraldine Smith06/07/2006Morecambe and LunesdaleLabourSigned
Michael Mates06/07/2006East HampshireConservativeSigned
Roger Godsiff12/07/2006Birmingham, Sparkbrook and Small HeathLabourSigned
Tony Lloyd17/07/2006Manchester CentralLabourSigned
John Whittingdale17/07/2006Maldon and East ChelmsfordConservativeSigned
Doug Henderson24/07/2006Newcastle upon Tyne NorthLabourSigned
Paul Farrelly24/07/2006Newcastle-under-LymeLabourSigned
John Randall25/07/2006UxbridgeConservativeSigned
Hywel Williams25/07/2006CaernarfonPlaid CymruSigned
Nicholas Soames09/10/2006Mid SussexConservativeSigned
Christopher Huhne09/10/2006EastleighLiberal DemocratSigned
Tom Brake11/10/2006Carshalton and WallingtonLiberal DemocratSigned
Susan Kramer12/10/2006Richmond ParkLiberal DemocratSigned
Joan Walley17/10/2006Stoke-on-Trent NorthLabourSigned
Nick Harvey20/10/2006North DevonLiberal DemocratSigned
Jennifer Willott30/10/2006Cardiff CentralLiberal DemocratSigned
Dai Davies06/11/2006Blaenau GwentIndependentSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.