Parliament Website

Nice Appeal Decision On Alimta For Mesothelioma

EDM number 729 in 2006-07, proposed by Michael Clapham on 24/01/2007.

That this House is aware that since July 2005 mesothelioma victims in Scotland have had access to the drug Alimta, which is the only licensed treatment for this tumour; welcomes the decision of the Cancer Networks and primary care trusts that have made Alimta available in parts of England and Wales; urges them and NHS Quality Improvement Scotland to stand by their decision irrespective of what the National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) finally decides; welcomes the decision by NICE announced on 19th December 2006 to uphold four of the grounds raised at the Alimta appeal hearing; notes that the use of Cost per Life Year Gained and other matters will now be reconsidered by the Appraisal Committee; further notes that Alimta is priced lower in the UK than in other European countries and that the NHS budget impact for 2007 will only be £3 million; urges the Government to review the appraisal methodology used by NICE; recognises the additional duty of care on Government to workers from the former nationalised industries negligently exposed to asbestos; and calls on the Secretary of State for Health to acknowledge that, in this case, she has a wider social responsibility that goes beyond the NICE definition of cost-effectiveness.

This motion has been signed by a total of 90 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Michael Clapham24/01/2007Barnsley West & PenistoneLabourProposed
David Hamilton24/01/2007MidlothianLabourSeconded
Peter Kilfoyle24/01/2007Liverpool, WaltonLabourSeconded
Jim Dobbin24/01/2007Heywood & MiddletonLabourSeconded
Lindsay Hoyle24/01/2007ChorleyLabourSeconded
Albert Owen24/01/2007Ynys MLabourSeconded
Frank Cook24/01/2007Stockton NorthLabourSigned
Jim Cunningham24/01/2007Coventry SouthLabourSigned
Ian Davidson24/01/2007Glasgow South WestLabourSigned
Bill Etherington24/01/2007Sunderland NorthLabourSigned
Andrew George24/01/2007St IvesLiberal DemocratSigned
Bill Olner24/01/2007NuneatonLabourSigned
John McDonnell24/01/2007Hayes & HarlingtonLabourSigned
Ken Purchase24/01/2007Wolverhampton North EastLabourSigned
Bob Spink24/01/2007Castle PointConservativeSigned
Jimmy Hood24/01/2007Lanark & Hamilton EastLabourSigned
Kelvin Hopkins24/01/2007Luton NorthLabourSigned
Rob Marris24/01/2007Wolverhampton South WestLabourSigned
David Drew25/01/2007StroudLabourSigned
Jeff Ennis25/01/2007Barnsley East & MexboroughLabourSigned
Ian Gibson25/01/2007Norwich NorthLabourSigned
Hugh Bayley25/01/2007York, City ofLabourSigned
David Borrow25/01/2007South RibbleLabourSigned
Peter Bottomley25/01/2007Worthing WestConservativeSigned
David Taylor25/01/2007North West LeicestershireLabourSigned
Robert Wareing25/01/2007Liverpool, West DerbyLabourSigned
Nicholas Winterton25/01/2007MacclesfieldConservativeSigned
Lee Scott25/01/2007Ilford NorthConservativeSigned
Nigel Dodds25/01/2007Belfast NorthDUPSigned
Andrew Dismore25/01/2007HendonLabourSigned
Greg Pope25/01/2007HyndburnLabourSigned
Gordon Prentice25/01/2007PendleLabourSigned
Alan Simpson25/01/2007Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
Dennis Skinner25/01/2007BolsoverLabourSigned
Paul Holmes25/01/2007ChesterfieldLiberal DemocratSigned
Brian Iddon25/01/2007Bolton South EastLabourSigned
Martin Caton25/01/2007GowerLabourSigned
David Clelland25/01/2007Tyne BridgeLabourSigned
John Cummings25/01/2007EasingtonLabourSigned
Janet Dean25/01/2007BurtonLabourSigned
Derek Wyatt26/01/2007Sittingbourne & SheppeyLabourSigned
Derek Conway26/01/2007Old Bexley & SidcupConservativeSigned
Nick Harvey26/01/2007North DevonLiberal DemocratSigned
David Anderson29/01/2007BlaydonLabourSigned
Betty Williams29/01/2007ConwyLabourSigned
Mike Hancock29/01/2007Portsmouth SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
Nigel Evans29/01/2007Ribble ValleyConservativeSigned
Colin Breed29/01/2007South East CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
David Heyes29/01/2007Ashton-under-LyneLabourSigned
Hywel Williams30/01/2007CaernarfonPlaid CymruSigned
Roger Godsiff30/01/2007Birmingham, Sparkbrook & Small HeathLabourSigned
Neil Gerrard30/01/2007WalthamstowLabourSigned
Alan Meale30/01/2007MansfieldLabourSigned
Fraser Kemp30/01/2007Houghton & Washington EastLabourSigned
Ann Cryer31/01/2007KeighleyLabourSigned
David Crausby31/01/2007Bolton North EastLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn31/01/2007Islington NorthLabourSigned
Ronnie Campbell31/01/2007Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
Stephen Hepburn01/02/2007JarrowLabourSigned
Edward O'Hara01/02/2007Knowsley SouthLabourSigned
Hywel Francis01/02/2007AberavonLabourSigned
Chris McCafferty02/02/2007Calder ValleyLabourSigned
Rudi Vis05/02/2007Finchley & Golders GreenLabourSigned
Andrew Stunell05/02/2007Hazel GroveLiberal DemocratSigned
Brian Jenkins06/02/2007TamworthLabourSigned
Alasdair McDonnell06/02/2007Belfast SouthSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Doug Naysmith07/02/2007Bristol North WestLabourSigned
Jo Swinson07/02/2007East DunbartonshireLiberal DemocratSigned
Eric Illsley08/02/2007Barnsley CentralLabourSigned
John Pugh08/02/2007SouthportLiberal DemocratSigned
Ian Stewart19/02/2007EcclesLabourSigned
Katy Clark19/02/2007Ayrshire North & ArranLabourSigned
John Leech20/02/2007Manchester, WithingtonLiberal DemocratSigned
Linda Riordan20/02/2007HalifaxLabourSigned
John Hemming27/02/2007Birmingham, YardleyLiberal DemocratSigned
Christopher Huhne27/02/2007EastleighLiberal DemocratSigned
Geoffrey Robinson07/03/2007Coventry North WestLabourSigned
Paul Rowen18/04/2007RochdaleLiberal DemocratSigned
Nicholas Clegg04/06/2007Sheffield, HallamLiberal DemocratSigned
Richard Shepherd04/06/2007Aldridge-BrownhillsConservativeSigned
Jim Sheridan05/06/2007Paisley & Renfrewshire NorthLabourSigned
Sandra Osborne06/06/2007Ayr, Carrick & CumnockLabourSigned
Gavin Strang06/06/2007Edinburgh EastLabourSigned
Ann McKechin11/06/2007Glasgow NorthLabourSigned
David Marshall11/06/2007Glasgow EastLabourSigned
Joan Humble20/06/2007Blackpool North & FleetwoodLabourSigned
Michael Connarty21/06/2007Linlithgow & Falkirk EastLabourSigned
Paul Farrelly28/06/2007Newcastle-under-LymeLabourSigned
Bob Laxton03/07/2007Derby NorthLabourSigned
Paul Truswell03/07/2007PudseyLabourSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.