Parliament Website

Pensions Clawback

EDM number 557 in 1998-99, proposed by Kerry Pollard on 19/04/1999.

That this House believes that the practice of integrating occupational pensions with the state pension, commonly known as clawback, which allows employers to deduct a significant proportion of their employees' pension, affecting up to 2.5 million pensioners across the United Kingdom and hitting the lowest paid and part-time workers hardest, is unfair, as pensioners who have paid national insurance contributions all their working lives are entitled to benefit from the provisions intended by Government to be available to all; and believes that the Government should legislate to phase out this practice, following the example set by the Republic of Ireland where a recently introduced Bill, which has the full support of the Irish Government, states that the amount deducted from occupational pension payments by trustees of pension schemes cannot increase when the amount of the state pension is increased, effectively freezing the amount which can be deducted.

This motion has been signed by a total of 200 MPs, 3 of these signatures have been withdrawn.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Kerry Pollard19/04/1999St AlbansLabourProposed
Brian Iddon19/04/1999Bolton South EastLabourSigned
Tony McWalter19/04/1999Hemel HempsteadLabour Co-operativeSigned
Desmond Turner19/04/1999Brighton, KemptownLabourSigned
Alan Simpson20/04/1999Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
Martin Smyth20/04/1999Belfast SouthUUPSigned
Vincent Cable20/04/1999TwickenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
David Chaytor20/04/1999Bury NorthLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn20/04/1999Islington NorthLabourSigned
Valerie Davey20/04/1999Bristol WestLabourSigned
Paul Flynn20/04/1999Newport WestLabourSigned
Norman Godman20/04/1999Greenock & InverclydeLabourSigned
Harry Barnes20/04/1999North East DerbyshireLabourSigned
David Taylor20/04/1999North West LeicestershireLabour Co-operativeSigned
Bob Russell21/04/1999ColchesterLiberal DemocratSigned
Eric Illsley21/04/1999Barnsley CentralLabourSigned
Nigel Jones21/04/1999CheltenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
Paul Keetch21/04/1999HerefordLiberal DemocratSigned
Elfyn Llwyd21/04/1999Meirionnydd Nant ConwyPlaid CymruSigned
Bill Michie21/04/1999Sheffield, HeeleyLabourSigned
Edward O'Hara21/04/1999Knowsley SouthLabourSigned
Ronnie Campbell21/04/1999Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
John Cummings21/04/1999EasingtonLabourSigned
Ronnie Fearn21/04/1999SouthportLiberal DemocratSigned
Maria Fyfe21/04/1999Glasgow, MaryhillLabourSigned
Ian Gibson21/04/1999Norwich NorthLabourSigned
Audrey Wise21/04/1999PrestonLabourSigned
Evan Harris22/04/1999Oxford West & AbingdonLiberal DemocratSigned
Stephen Hesford22/04/1999Wirral WestLabourSigned
Terry Lewis22/04/1999WorsleyLabourSigned
John McDonnell22/04/1999Hayes & HarlingtonLabourSigned
Christine Butler22/04/1999Castle PointLabourSigned
Martin Caton22/04/1999GowerLabourSigned
Eric Clarke22/04/1999MidlothianLabourSigned
Jim Dobbin22/04/1999Heywood & MiddletonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Bill Etherington22/04/1999Sunderland NorthLabourSigned
Bob Blizzard22/04/1999WaveneyLabourSigned
George Stevenson22/04/1999Stoke-on-Trent SouthLabourSigned
Nick Palmer23/04/1999BroxtoweLabourSigned
Lawrence Cunliffe23/04/1999LeighLabourSigned
David Kidney26/04/1999StaffordLabourSigned
Michael Clark26/04/1999RayleighConservativeSigned
Jim Fitzpatrick26/04/1999Poplar & Canning TownLabourSigned
Joan Ruddock27/04/1999Lewisham, DeptfordLabourSigned
Lynne Jones27/04/1999Birmingham, Selly OakLabourSigned
Bob Laxton27/04/1999Derby NorthLabourSigned
Andrew Love27/04/1999EdmontonLabour Co-operativeSigned
John McAllion27/04/1999Dundee EastLabourSigned
Laura Moffatt27/04/1999CrawleyLabourSigned
Michael Moore27/04/1999Tweeddale, Ettrick & LauderdaleLiberal DemocratSigned
Colin Breed27/04/1999South East CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Harry Cohen27/04/1999Leyton & WansteadLabourSigned
Michael Colvin27/04/1999RomseyConservativeSigned
Neil Gerrard27/04/1999WalthamstowLabourSigned
John Greenway27/04/1999RyedaleConservativeSigned
John Austin27/04/1999Erith & ThamesmeadLabourSigned
Alan Beith27/04/1999Berwick-upon-TweedLiberal DemocratSigned
Gerry Steinberg27/04/1999Durham, City ofLabourSigned
Paul Stinchcombe27/04/1999WellingboroughLabourSigned
Desmond Swayne27/04/1999New Forest WestConservativeSigned
Betty Williams27/04/1999ConwyLabourSigned
Phil Willis27/04/1999Harrogate & KnaresboroughLiberal DemocratSigned
Nicholas Winterton27/04/1999MacclesfieldConservativeSigned
Peter Pike28/04/1999BurnleyLabourSigned
Ivan Henderson28/04/1999HarwichLabourSigned
Martyn Jones28/04/1999Clwyd SouthLabourSigned
Eddie McGrady28/04/1999South DownSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Martin O'Neill28/04/1999OchilLabourSigned
Ian Cawsey28/04/1999Brigg & GooleLabourSigned
Michael Clapham28/04/1999Barnsley West & PenistoneLabourSigned
Claire Curtis-Thomas28/04/1999CrosbyLabourSigned
Margaret Ewing28/04/1999MorayScottish National PartySigned
Llin Golding28/04/1999Newcastle-under-LymeLabourSigned
Martin Bell28/04/1999TattonIndependentSigned
Harold Best28/04/1999Leeds North WestLabourSigned
David Borrow28/04/1999South RibbleLabourSigned
Peter Robinson29/04/1999Belfast EastDUPSigned
Marsha Singh29/04/1999Bradford WestLabourSigned
Dennis Skinner29/04/1999BolsoverLabourSigned
Phyllis Starkey29/04/1999Milton Keynes South WestLabourSigned
John Maxton29/04/1999Glasgow, CathcartLabourSigned
Austin Mitchell29/04/1999Great GrimsbyLabourSigned
Michael Connarty29/04/1999Falkirk EastLabourSigned
John Cryer29/04/1999HornchurchLabourSigned
Janet Dean29/04/1999BurtonLabourSigned
Maria Eagle29/04/1999Liverpool, GarstonLabourSigned
Gerry Bermingham29/04/1999St Helens SouthLabourSigned
Andrew Stunell29/04/1999Hazel GroveLiberal DemocratSigned
Alan Williams29/04/1999Carmarthen East & DinefwrLabourSigned
Derek Wyatt29/04/1999Sittingbourne & SheppeyLabourSigned
Stephen Pound30/04/1999Ealing NorthLabourSigned
Bill Olner30/04/1999NuneatonLabourSigned
Ron Davies30/04/1999CaerphillyLabourSigned
Charlotte Atkins30/04/1999Staffordshire MoorlandsLabourSigned
Dave Watts30/04/1999St Helens NorthLabourSigned
Tom Pendry04/05/1999Stalybridge & HydeLabourSigned
Ernie Ross04/05/1999Dundee WestLabourSigned
Ken Maginnis04/05/1999Fermanagh & South TyroneUUPSigned
Diana Organ04/05/1999Forest of DeanLabourSigned
Colin Burgon04/05/1999ElmetLabourSigned
Ann Cryer04/05/1999KeighleyLabourSigned
Diane Abbott04/05/1999Hackney North & Stoke NewingtonLabourSigned
Syd Rapson05/05/1999Portsmouth NorthLabourSigned
Allan Rogers05/05/1999RhonddaLabourSigned
Peter Snape05/05/1999West Bromwich EastLabourSigned
David Hinchliffe05/05/1999WakefieldLabourSigned
Ieuan Wyn Jones05/05/1999Ynys MPlaid CymruSigned
Stephen Ladyman05/05/1999South ThanetLabourSigned
Ken Livingstone05/05/1999Brent EastLabourSigned
Frank Cook05/05/1999Stockton NorthLabourSigned
Derek Foster05/05/1999Bishop AucklandLabourSigned
Liz Blackman05/05/1999ErewashLabourSigned
Ian Stewart05/05/1999EcclesLabourSigned
Jenny Tonge05/05/1999Richmond ParkLiberal DemocratSigned
Sandra Osborne06/05/1999AyrLabourSigned
Gwyneth Dunwoody06/05/1999Crewe & NantwichLabourSigned
Tony Worthington07/05/1999Clydebank & MilngavieLabourSigned
Paul Burstow10/05/1999Sutton & CheamLiberal DemocratSigned
Phil Sawford11/05/1999KetteringLabourSigned
Russell Brown11/05/1999DumfriesLabourSigned
Karen Buck11/05/1999Regent's Park and Kensington NorthLabourSigned
David Drew11/05/1999StroudLabour Co-operativeSigned
Fabian Hamilton11/05/1999Leeds North EastLabourSigned
Mike Wood11/05/1999Batley & SpenLabourSigned
Tony Wright11/05/1999Cannock ChaseLabourSigned
Gwyn Prosser12/05/1999DoverLabourSigned
Adrian Sanders12/05/1999TorbayLiberal DemocratSigned
Angela Smith12/05/1999BasildonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Peter Temple-Morris12/05/1999LeominsterLabourSigned
Julie Morgan13/05/1999Cardiff NorthLabourSigned
Richard Livsey13/05/1999Brecon & RadnorshireLiberal DemocratSigned
Michael Mates13/05/1999East HampshireConservativeSigned
Graham Brady13/05/1999Altrincham & Sale WestConservativeSigned
Jeff Ennis13/05/1999Barnsley East & MexboroughLabourSigned
Don Foster13/05/1999BathLiberal DemocratSigned
Andrew George13/05/1999St IvesLiberal DemocratSigned
Patrick Hall13/05/1999BedfordLabourSigned
Paul Truswell13/05/1999PudseyLabourSigned
John Wilkinson13/05/1999Ruislip - NorthwoodConservativeSigned
Geraldine Smith14/05/1999Morecambe & LunesdaleLabourSigned
Peter Brand14/05/1999Isle of WightLiberal DemocratSigned
Jamie Cann14/05/1999IpswichLabourSigned
Mike Hancock14/05/1999Portsmouth SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
Matthew Taylor14/05/1999Truro & St AustellLiberal DemocratSigned
Jimmy Wray14/05/1999Glasgow, BailliestonLabourSigned
Jimmy Hood17/05/1999ClydesdaleLabourSigned
Ashok Kumar17/05/1999Middlesbrough South & East ClevelandLabourSigned
Tom Cox17/05/1999TootingLabourSigned
Howard Flight17/05/1999Arundel & South DownsConservativeSigned
Clifford Forsythe17/05/1999South AntrimUUPSigned
Donald Gorrie17/05/1999Edinburgh WestLiberal DemocratSigned
Roy Beggs17/05/1999East AntrimUUPSigned
Cecil Walker17/05/1999Belfast NorthUUPSigned
Anthony D Wright17/05/1999Great YarmouthLabourSigned
Bill Rammell18/05/1999HarlowLabourSigned
Julie Kirkbride18/05/1999BromsgroveConservativeSigned
Brian Cotter18/05/1999Weston-Super-MareLiberal DemocratSigned
Edward Davey18/05/1999Kingston & SurbitonLiberal DemocratSigned
Joe Ashton18/05/1999BassetlawLabourSigned
Norman Baker18/05/1999LewesLiberal DemocratSigned
Brian White18/05/1999North East Milton KeynesLabourSigned
John Horam19/05/1999OrpingtonConservativeSigned
Ann Clwyd19/05/1999Cynon ValleyLabourSigned
Jim Cunningham19/05/1999Coventry SouthLabourSigned
Rudi Vis19/05/1999Finchley & Golders GreenLabourSigned
Joan Walley19/05/1999Stoke-on-Trent NorthLabourSigned
Doug Naysmith20/05/1999Bristol North WestLabour Co-operativeSigned
Howard Stoate20/05/1999DartfordLabourSigned
Ian Davidson21/05/1999Glasgow, PollokLabour Co-operativeSigned
Richard Allan21/05/1999Sheffield, HallamLiberal DemocratSigned
Malcolm Savidge24/05/1999Aberdeen NorthLabourSigned
William Ross25/05/1999East LondonderryUUPSigned
Tom Brake25/05/1999Carshalton & WallingtonLiberal DemocratSigned
David Chidgey25/05/1999EastleighLiberal DemocratSigned
Kelvin Hopkins08/06/1999Luton NorthLabourSigned
Stephen McCabe08/06/1999Birmingham, Hall GreenLabourSigned
Ian Paisley08/06/1999North AntrimDUPSigned
Gordon Marsden09/06/1999Blackpool SouthLabourSigned
Jim Cousins10/06/1999Newcastle upon Tyne CentralLabourSigned
Mark Oaten15/06/1999WinchesterLiberal DemocratSigned
Michael Jabez Foster15/06/1999Hastings & RyeLabourSigned
Christine Russell16/06/1999Chester, City ofLabourSigned
Dafydd Wigley16/06/1999CaernarfonPlaid CymruSigned
Charles Wardle17/06/1999Bexhill & BattleConservativeSigned
John Grogan22/06/1999SelbyLabourSigned
Candy Atherton24/06/1999Falmouth & CamborneLabourSigned
Andy King25/06/1999Rugby & KenilworthLabourSigned
Alan Campbell25/06/1999TynemouthLabourSigned
John Randall30/06/1999UxbridgeConservativeSigned
Hilary Benn13/07/1999Leeds CentralLabourSigned
Terry Davis21/07/1999Birmingham, Hodge HillLabourSigned
Tony Clarke27/07/1999Northampton SouthLabourSigned
Win Griffiths27/07/1999BridgendLabourSigned
John Hume19/10/1999FoyleSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
David Lepper19/10/1999Brighton, PavilionLabour Co-operativeSigned
Seamus Mallon19/10/1999Newry & ArmaghSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Denzil Davies08/11/1999LlanelliLabourSigned
Graham StringerUnknownWithdrawn
Chris MullinUnknownWithdrawn
Malcolm WicksUnknownWithdrawn

Download raw data as csv or xml.