Parliament Website

NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR CLINICAL EXCELLENCE DECISION ON ALZHEIMER'S TREATMENT

EDM number 824 in 2004-05, proposed by HELEN CLARK on 02/03/2005.

That this House notes that Alzheimer's disease currently affects nearly half a million people in the UK and that it is a chronic, progressive, degenerative and distressing disease for which there is no cure; deplores the cost-cutting plans of the National Institute for Clinical Excellence which will deny vital drugs to hundreds of thousands of Alzheimer's sufferers, claiming that they are too expensive when they would cost the National Health Service a meagre ú2.50 per day; further notes that the effective proposed ban on these drugs is not based on their safety and efficacy but simply on the interpretation of a statistical model of cost-effectiveness; further notes that doctors have condemned this decision as a disaster for patients, their families and carers; and that they believe that it would be irresponsible to deny patients and their carers the benefits of these treatments; further notes that the decision goes against good clinical practice and represents a callous disregard for elderly people; recognises that the Government should recommend drugs based on clinical need; applauds the Daily Mail's campaign for the retention of these drugs; and calls upon the Government to reject this advice.

This motion has been signed by a total of 104 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Helen Clark02/03/2005PeterboroughLabourProposed
Anthony Steen02/03/2005TotnesConservativeSigned
Harold Best02/03/2005Leeds North WestLabourSigned
John Bercow02/03/2005BuckinghamConservativeSigned
David Amess02/03/2005Southend WestConservativeSigned
Jane Griffiths02/03/2005Reading EastLabourSigned
Ian Gibson02/03/2005Norwich NorthLabourSigned
Edward Garnier02/03/2005HarboroughConservativeSigned
Jim Cunningham02/03/2005Coventry SouthLabourSigned
Si02/03/2005Birmingham, ErdingtonLabourSigned
Julie Kirkbride02/03/2005BromsgroveConservativeSigned
Alice Mahon02/03/2005HalifaxLabourSigned
John McWilliam02/03/2005BlaydonLabourSigned
Ronnie Campbell02/03/2005Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
Nicholas Winterton03/03/2005MacclesfieldConservativeSigned
Paul Tyler03/03/2005North CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Desmond Turner03/03/2005Brighton, KemptownLabourSigned
David Drew03/03/2005StroudLabour Co-operativeSigned
Alan Meale03/03/2005MansfieldLabourSigned
Elfyn Llwyd03/03/2005Meirionnydd Nant ConwyPlaid CymruSigned
Eric Illsley03/03/2005Barnsley CentralLabourSigned
Bob Spink03/03/2005Castle PointConservativeSigned
Martin Smyth03/03/2005Belfast SouthUUPSigned
Nigel Evans04/03/2005Ribble ValleyConservativeSigned
Michael Clapham04/03/2005Barnsley West & PenistoneLabourSigned
Chris McCafferty04/03/2005Calder ValleyLabourSigned
Paul Marsden04/03/2005Shrewsbury & AtchamLiberal DemocratSigned
Ann Winterton07/03/2005CongletonConservativeSigned
Rudi Vis07/03/2005Finchley & Golders GreenLabourSigned
David Taylor07/03/2005North West LeicestershireLabour Co-operativeSigned
Mike Hancock07/03/2005Portsmouth SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
Neil Gerrard07/03/2005WalthamstowLabourSigned
Andrew George07/03/2005St IvesLiberal DemocratSigned
John Cryer07/03/2005HornchurchLabourSigned
Jim Cousins07/03/2005Newcastle upon Tyne CentralLabourSigned
Sydney Chapman07/03/2005Chipping BarnetConservativeSigned
Adam Price07/03/2005Carmarthen East & DinefwrPlaid CymruSigned
John Cummings08/03/2005EasingtonLabourSigned
Nigel Dodds08/03/2005Belfast NorthDUPSigned
Jeffrey M Donaldson08/03/2005Lagan ValleyDUPSigned
Peter Bottomley08/03/2005Worthing WestConservativeSigned
Gerry Steinberg08/03/2005Durham, City ofLabourSigned
Jenny Tonge08/03/2005Richmond ParkLiberal DemocratSigned
Derek Wyatt08/03/2005Sittingbourne & SheppeyLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn08/03/2005Islington NorthLabourSigned
Tony Colman08/03/2005PutneyLabourSigned
Syd Rapson08/03/2005Portsmouth NorthLabourSigned
Stephen Hepburn08/03/2005JarrowLabourSigned
Paul Holmes08/03/2005ChesterfieldLiberal DemocratSigned
Kevin McNamara08/03/2005Kingston upon Hull NorthLabourSigned
Albert Owen08/03/2005Ynys MLabourSigned
Keith Bradley08/03/2005Manchester, WithingtonLabourSigned
Martin Caton08/03/2005GowerLabourSigned
Dennis Turner09/03/2005Wolverhampton South EastLabour Co-operativeSigned
Janet Anderson09/03/2005Rossendale & DarwenLabourSigned
Sandra Gidley09/03/2005RomseyLiberal DemocratSigned
Jeff Ennis09/03/2005Barnsley East & MexboroughLabourSigned
Huw Edwards09/03/2005MonmouthLabourSigned
Jim Dobbin09/03/2005Heywood & MiddletonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Tom Cox09/03/2005TootingLabourSigned
Gregory Campbell09/03/2005East LondonderryDUPSigned
Terry Lewis09/03/2005WorsleyLabourSigned
Lindsay Hoyle09/03/2005ChorleyLabourSigned
Hywel Francis10/03/2005AberavonLabourSigned
Win Griffiths10/03/2005BridgendLabourSigned
David Borrow10/03/2005South RibbleLabourSigned
Joan Walley10/03/2005Stoke-on-Trent NorthLabourSigned
David Clelland10/03/2005Tyne BridgeLabourSigned
Tony Clarke10/03/2005Northampton SouthLabourSigned
Colin Breed10/03/2005South East CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Nigel Jones10/03/2005CheltenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
Kelvin Hopkins10/03/2005Luton NorthLabourSigned
Lady Hermon10/03/2005North DownUUPSigned
Andy Reed10/03/2005LoughboroughLabour Co-operativeSigned
Anne Campbell14/03/2005CambridgeLabourSigned
Ann Cryer14/03/2005KeighleyLabourSigned
Harry Barnes14/03/2005North East DerbyshireLabourSigned
John Battle14/03/2005Leeds WestLabourSigned
Annette Brooke14/03/2005Mid Dorset & North PooleLiberal DemocratSigned
Sandra Osborne14/03/2005AyrLabourSigned
John McDonnell14/03/2005Hayes & HarlingtonLabourSigned
David Marshall14/03/2005Glasgow, ShettlestonLabourSigned
Piara S Khabra14/03/2005Ealing, SouthallLabourSigned
Alan Simpson14/03/2005Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
Llew Smith15/03/2005Blaenau GwentLabourSigned
John Mann16/03/2005BassetlawLabourSigned
Parmjit Gill17/03/2005Leicester SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
David Heyes17/03/2005Ashton-under-LyneLabourSigned
Alan Keen18/03/2005Feltham & HestonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Bill Olner18/03/2005NuneatonLabourSigned
David Chidgey21/03/2005EastleighLiberal DemocratSigned
John Grogan22/03/2005SelbyLabourSigned
Janet Dean22/03/2005BurtonLabourSigned
Tam Dalyell22/03/2005LinlithgowLabourSigned
Diana Organ22/03/2005Forest of DeanLabourSigned
Doug Naysmith22/03/2005Bristol North WestLabour Co-operativeSigned
Joan Ruddock22/03/2005Lewisham, DeptfordLabourSigned
Valerie Davey23/03/2005Bristol WestLabourSigned
Joe Benton23/03/2005BootleLabourSigned
Brian White24/03/2005North East Milton KeynesLabourSigned
Gordon Prentice24/03/2005PendleLabourSigned
Stephen Pound24/03/2005Ealing NorthLabourSigned
John Barrett04/04/2005Edinburgh WestLiberal DemocratSigned
Richard Younger-Ross04/04/2005TeignbridgeLiberal DemocratSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.