Parliament Website

Discrimination In Disability Benefits

EDM number 953 in 2003-04, proposed by Roger Berry on 31/03/2004.

That this House believes that it is injust and discriminatory to deny people who become disabled from the age of 65 the opportunity to claim disability living allowance; further believes that the alternative benefit offered to older disabled people, attendance allowance, is inadequate because it does not contain a mobility component, is not available to those with lower-level needs and requires a claimant to wait three months longer before making a claim; notes further that attendance allowance does not passport its recipients to the Motability scheme, or exemption from vehicle exise duty; further believes that this differentiation between older and younger disabled people is based on an outmoded and unfounded conception of older people as inactive and non-contributing members of society; and therefore urges the Government to support the aims of the Mobilise campaign, to end age discrimination in disability benefit and make a genuine commitment to active ageing and the full participatory citizenship of older people.

This motion has been signed by a total of 244 MPs, 1 of these signatures have been withdrawn.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Roger Berry31/03/2004KingswoodLabourProposed
Paul Burstow31/03/2004Sutton & CheamLiberal DemocratSigned
Ronnie Campbell31/03/2004Blyth ValleyLabourSigned
Peter Bottomley31/03/2004Worthing WestConservativeSigned
Simon Thomas31/03/2004CeredigionPlaid CymruSigned
Martin Smyth01/04/2004Belfast SouthUUPSigned
Bob Spink01/04/2004Castle PointConservativeSigned
Paul Holmes01/04/2004ChesterfieldLiberal DemocratSigned
Simon Hughes01/04/2004North Southwark & BermondseyLiberal DemocratSigned
Eric Illsley01/04/2004Barnsley CentralLabourSigned
Lynne Jones01/04/2004Birmingham, Selly OakLabourSigned
Kevin McNamara01/04/2004Kingston upon Hull NorthLabourSigned
Gregory Campbell01/04/2004East LondonderryDUPSigned
Sue Doughty01/04/2004GuildfordLiberal DemocratSigned
Andrew George01/04/2004St IvesLiberal DemocratSigned
Win Griffiths01/04/2004BridgendLabourSigned
Harry Barnes01/04/2004North East DerbyshireLabourSigned
Desmond Turner01/04/2004Brighton, KemptownLabourSigned
Paul Tyler01/04/2004North CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Michael Weir01/04/2004AngusScottish National PartySigned
Adam Price19/04/2004Carmarthen East & DinefwrPlaid CymruSigned
Lindsay Hoyle19/04/2004ChorleyLabourSigned
Chris McCafferty19/04/2004Calder ValleyLabourSigned
Martin Caton19/04/2004GowerLabourSigned
Jeremy Corbyn19/04/2004Islington NorthLabourSigned
Annabelle Ewing19/04/2004PerthScottish National PartySigned
Robert Wareing19/04/2004Liverpool, West DerbyLabourSigned
Betty Williams19/04/2004ConwyLabourSigned
Phil Sawford20/04/2004KetteringLabourSigned
Paul Keetch20/04/2004HerefordLiberal DemocratSigned
Alan Meale20/04/2004MansfieldLabourSigned
Tom Brake20/04/2004Carshalton & WallingtonLiberal DemocratSigned
Colin Burgon20/04/2004ElmetLabourSigned
Ann Cryer20/04/2004KeighleyLabourSigned
Jim Dobbin20/04/2004Heywood & MiddletonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Huw Edwards20/04/2004MonmouthLabourSigned
Vera Baird20/04/2004RedcarLabourSigned
Roy Beggs20/04/2004East AntrimUUPSigned
Paul Stinchcombe20/04/2004WellingboroughLabourSigned
Rudi Vis20/04/2004Finchley & Golders GreenLabourSigned
Hywel Williams20/04/2004CaernarfonPlaid CymruSigned
Gwyn Prosser21/04/2004DoverLabourSigned
Ernie Ross21/04/2004Dundee WestLabourSigned
Nigel Jones21/04/2004CheltenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
Elfyn Llwyd21/04/2004Meirionnydd Nant ConwyPlaid CymruSigned
John McDonnell21/04/2004Hayes & HarlingtonLabourSigned
Denis Murphy21/04/2004WansbeckLabourSigned
Albert Owen21/04/2004Ynys MLabourSigned
Annette Brooke21/04/2004Mid Dorset & North PooleLiberal DemocratSigned
Richard Burden21/04/2004Birmingham, NorthfieldLabourSigned
David Drew21/04/2004StroudLabour Co-operativeSigned
Hywel Francis21/04/2004AberavonLabourSigned
Neil Gerrard21/04/2004WalthamstowLabourSigned
Tony Baldry21/04/2004BanburyConservativeSigned
Alan Simpson22/04/2004Nottingham SouthLabourSigned
David Heath22/04/2004Somerton & FromeLiberal DemocratSigned
Lady Hermon22/04/2004North DownUUPSigned
Piara S Khabra22/04/2004Ealing, SouthallLabourSigned
David Kidney22/04/2004StaffordLabourSigned
Harry Cohen22/04/2004Leyton & WansteadLabourSigned
Janet Dean22/04/2004BurtonLabourSigned
David Hamilton22/04/2004MidlothianLabourSigned
Andrew Stunell22/04/2004Hazel GroveLiberal DemocratSigned
Desmond Swayne26/04/2004New Forest WestConservativeSigned
Nigel Dodds27/04/2004Belfast NorthDUPSigned
Paul Marsden28/04/2004Shrewsbury & AtchamLiberal DemocratSigned
Alan Hurst30/04/2004BraintreeLabourSigned
Bob Russell04/05/2004ColchesterLiberal DemocratSigned
Clive Efford04/05/2004ElthamLabourSigned
David Amess04/05/2004Southend WestConservativeSigned
John Barrett04/05/2004Edinburgh WestLiberal DemocratSigned
Nicholas Winterton04/05/2004MacclesfieldConservativeSigned
Bill Etherington05/05/2004Sunderland NorthLabourSigned
Linda Perham06/05/2004Ilford NorthLabourSigned
Keith Bradley06/05/2004Manchester, WithingtonLabourSigned
Brian White06/05/2004North East Milton KeynesLabourSigned
Virginia Bottomley10/05/2004South West SurreyConservativeSigned
Richard Taylor10/05/2004Wyre ForestIndependentSigned
Doug Henderson11/05/2004Newcastle upon Tyne NorthLabourSigned
Sandra Osborne11/05/2004AyrLabourSigned
John Greenway12/05/2004RyedaleConservativeSigned
Paul Flynn13/05/2004Newport WestLabourSigned
Alan Beith13/05/2004Berwick-upon-TweedLiberal DemocratSigned
Graham Stringer17/05/2004Manchester, BlackleyLabourSigned
Derek Wyatt17/05/2004Sittingbourne & SheppeyLabourSigned
John Randall18/05/2004UxbridgeConservativeSigned
Kate Hoey18/05/2004VauxhallLabourSigned
Colin Breed18/05/2004South East CornwallLiberal DemocratSigned
Tony Colman19/05/2004PutneyLabourSigned
Andrew Selous20/05/2004South West BedfordshireConservativeSigned
John Smith20/05/2004Vale of GlamorganLabourSigned
Edward Davey20/05/2004Kingston & SurbitonLiberal DemocratSigned
Hilton Dawson20/05/2004Lancaster & WyreLabourSigned
John Butterfill21/05/2004Bournemouth WestConservativeSigned
Stephen Dorrell21/05/2004CharnwoodConservativeSigned
Jenny Tonge21/05/2004Richmond ParkLiberal DemocratSigned
Robert Walter21/05/2004North DorsetConservativeSigned
Iain Coleman24/05/2004Hammersmith & FulhamLabourSigned
John Pugh25/05/2004SouthportLiberal DemocratSigned
Tony Clarke25/05/2004Northampton SouthLabourSigned
Richard Shepherd26/05/2004Aldridge-BrownhillsConservativeSigned
Julie Morgan27/05/2004Cardiff NorthLabourSigned
Christine Russell27/05/2004Chester, City ofLabourSigned
Helen Jackson27/05/2004Sheffield, HillsboroughLabourSigned
John Mann27/05/2004BassetlawLabourSigned
Adrian Sanders07/06/2004TorbayLiberal DemocratSigned
Malcolm Savidge07/06/2004Aberdeen NorthLabourSigned
Brian Sedgemore07/06/2004Hackney South & ShoreditchLabourSigned
Barry Sheerman07/06/2004HuddersfieldLabour Co-operativeSigned
Robert Smith07/06/2004West Aberdeenshire & KincardineLiberal DemocratSigned
David Heyes07/06/2004Ashton-under-LyneLabourSigned
Joan Humble07/06/2004Blackpool North & FleetwoodLabourSigned
Brian Iddon07/06/2004Bolton South EastLabourSigned
Diana Organ07/06/2004Forest of DeanLabourSigned
Anne Campbell07/06/2004CambridgeLabourSigned
Jim Cunningham07/06/2004Coventry SouthLabourSigned
Wayne David07/06/2004CaerphillyLabourSigned
Sarah Teather07/06/2004Brent EastLiberal DemocratSigned
John Wilkinson07/06/2004Ruislip - NorthwoodConservativeSigned
Michael Clapham08/06/2004Barnsley West & PenistoneLabourSigned
Glenda Jackson09/06/2004Hampstead & HighgateLabourSigned
Doug Naysmith09/06/2004Bristol North WestLabour Co-operativeSigned
Mark Oaten09/06/2004WinchesterLiberal DemocratSigned
Kevin Brennan09/06/2004Cardiff WestLabourSigned
Alistair Carmichael09/06/2004Orkney & ShetlandLiberal DemocratSigned
Tom Cox09/06/2004TootingLabourSigned
Richard Allan09/06/2004Sheffield, HallamLiberal DemocratSigned
Henry Bellingham09/06/2004North West NorfolkConservativeSigned
David Taylor09/06/2004North West LeicestershireLabour Co-operativeSigned
Peter Robinson10/06/2004Belfast EastDUPSigned
Parmjit Dhanda14/06/2004GloucesterLabourSigned
Eddie McGrady14/06/2004South DownSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Brian Cotter14/06/2004Weston-Super-MareLiberal DemocratSigned
Frank Roy15/06/2004Motherwell & WishawLabourSigned
David Burnside15/06/2004South AntrimUUPSigned
Brian H Donohoe15/06/2004Cunninghame SouthLabourSigned
John Taylor15/06/2004SolihullConservativeSigned
Gillian Shephard16/06/2004South West NorfolkConservativeSigned
Helen Clark16/06/2004PeterboroughLabourSigned
Peter Ainsworth16/06/2004East SurreyConservativeSigned
Tony Banks16/06/2004West HamLabourSigned
Alan Reid18/06/2004Argyll & ButeLiberal DemocratSigned
Geraldine Smith18/06/2004Morecambe & LunesdaleLabourSigned
Martyn Jones18/06/2004Clwyd SouthLabourSigned
Edward O'Hara18/06/2004Knowsley SouthLabourSigned
Jim Cousins18/06/2004Newcastle upon Tyne CentralLabourSigned
Lembit 21/06/2004MontgomeryshireLiberal DemocratSigned
Debra Shipley22/06/2004StourbridgeLabourSigned
Andrew Hunter22/06/2004BasingstokeIndependent ConservativeSigned
Peter Bradley22/06/2004Wrekin, TheLabourSigned
Harold Best22/06/2004Leeds North WestLabourSigned
Valerie Davey23/06/2004Bristol WestLabourSigned
Teddy Taylor23/06/2004Rochford & Southend EastConservativeSigned
Jonathan R Shaw24/06/2004Chatham & AylesfordLabourSigned
Joan Walley24/06/2004Stoke-on-Trent NorthLabourSigned
Jimmy Hood28/06/2004ClydesdaleLabourSigned
Andrew Dismore28/06/2004HendonLabourSigned
John Burnett29/06/2004Torridge & West DevonLiberal DemocratSigned
Chris Mole30/06/2004IpswichLabourSigned
Geoffrey Robinson01/07/2004Coventry North WestLabourSigned
Don Foster06/07/2004BathLiberal DemocratSigned
Dennis Turner06/07/2004Wolverhampton South EastLabour Co-operativeSigned
Bill Olner07/07/2004NuneatonLabourSigned
Paul Farrelly12/07/2004Newcastle-under-LymeLabourSigned
Roger Godsiff12/07/2004Birmingham, Sparkbrook & Small HeathLabourSigned
Llew Smith13/07/2004Blaenau GwentLabourSigned
Alex Salmond15/07/2004Banff & BuchanScottish National PartySigned
Ann Winterton15/07/2004CongletonConservativeSigned
Pete Wishart15/07/2004North TaysideScottish National PartySigned
Andy King16/07/2004Rugby & KenilworthLabourSigned
Gavin Strang16/07/2004Edinburgh East & MusselburghLabourSigned
Marion Roe19/07/2004BroxbourneConservativeSigned
Mark Lazarowicz19/07/2004Edinburgh North & LeithLabour Co-operativeSigned
Tony Lloyd19/07/2004Manchester CentralLabourSigned
Sydney Chapman19/07/2004Chipping BarnetConservativeSigned
Roger Williams19/07/2004Brecon & RadnorshireLiberal DemocratSigned
Syd Rapson20/07/2004Portsmouth NorthLabourSigned
Marsha Singh20/07/2004Bradford WestLabourSigned
Jeffrey M Donaldson20/07/2004Lagan ValleyDUPSigned
David Atkinson20/07/2004Bournemouth EastConservativeSigned
Tony Worthington20/07/2004Clydebank & MilngavieLabourSigned
John Robertson21/07/2004Glasgow, AnnieslandLabourSigned
Mark Hendrick21/07/2004PrestonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Ian Lucas21/07/2004WrexhamLabourSigned
Colin Challen21/07/2004Morley & RothwellLabourSigned
Ross Cranston21/07/2004Dudley NorthLabourSigned
John Cummings21/07/2004EasingtonLabourSigned
Barbara Follett21/07/2004StevenageLabourSigned
John Battle21/07/2004Leeds WestLabourSigned
John Thurso21/07/2004Caithness, Sutherland & Easter RossLiberal DemocratSigned
David Winnick21/07/2004Walsall NorthLabourSigned
John MacDougall22/07/2004Central FifeLabourSigned
Alice Mahon22/07/2004HalifaxLabourSigned
Vincent Cable22/07/2004TwickenhamLiberal DemocratSigned
Sandra Gidley22/07/2004RomseyLiberal DemocratSigned
Stephen Hepburn07/09/2004JarrowLabourSigned
George Howarth07/09/2004Knowsley North & Sefton EastLabourSigned
Robert Jackson07/09/2004WantageConservativeSigned
Brian Jenkins07/09/2004TamworthLabourSigned
Jon Owen Jones07/09/2004Cardiff CentralLabour Co-operativeSigned
Michael Mates07/09/2004East HampshireConservativeSigned
Austin Mitchell07/09/2004Great GrimsbyLabourSigned
Andrew Murrison07/09/2004WestburyConservativeSigned
Patsy Calton07/09/2004CheadleLiberal DemocratSigned
David Chidgey07/09/2004EastleighLiberal DemocratSigned
Michael Connarty07/09/2004Falkirk EastLabourSigned
Claire Curtis-Thomas07/09/2004CrosbyLabourSigned
Matthew Green07/09/2004LudlowLiberal DemocratSigned
Candy Atherton07/09/2004Falmouth & CamborneLabourSigned
John Austin07/09/2004Erith & ThamesmeadLabourSigned
Richard Younger-Ross07/09/2004TeignbridgeLiberal DemocratSigned
Tony Wright08/09/2004Cannock ChaseLabourSigned
Michael Spicer09/09/2004West WorcestershireConservativeSigned
Jim Dowd09/09/2004Lewisham WestLabourSigned
Frank Dobson13/09/2004Holborn & St PancrasLabourSigned
Terry Lewis14/09/2004WorsleyLabourSigned
David Chaytor15/09/2004Bury NorthLabourSigned
Joyce Quin16/09/2004Gateshead East & Washington WestLabourSigned
Phil Willis16/09/2004Harrogate & KnaresboroughLiberal DemocratSigned
Anthony D Wright16/09/2004Great YarmouthLabourSigned
James Plaskitt11/10/2004Warwick & LeamingtonLabourSigned
Iris Robinson11/10/2004StrangfordDUPSigned
Seamus Mallon11/10/2004Newry & ArmaghSocial Democratic and Labour PartySigned
Robert Marshall-Andrews11/10/2004MedwayLabourSigned
Jeff Ennis11/10/2004Barnsley East & MexboroughLabourSigned
Andrew Bennett11/10/2004Denton & ReddishLabourSigned
Andrew Rosindell12/10/2004RomfordConservativeSigned
Chris Smith12/10/2004Islington South & FinsburyLabourSigned
Jon Trickett12/10/2004HemsworthLabourSigned
David Trimble12/10/2004Upper BannUUPSigned
Sally Keeble13/10/2004Northampton NorthLabourSigned
Tom Clarke13/10/2004Coatbridge & ChrystonLabourSigned
Martin O'Neill14/10/2004OchilLabourSigned
John McWilliam21/10/2004BlaydonLabourSigned
Alan Keen28/10/2004Feltham & HestonLabour Co-operativeSigned
Michael Meacher02/11/2004Oldham West & RoytonLabourSigned
Kevin Barron02/11/2004Rother ValleyLabourSigned
Bob Blizzard02/11/2004WaveneyLabourSigned
Evan Harris03/11/2004Oxford West & AbingdonLiberal DemocratSigned
Norman Lamb08/11/2004North NorfolkLiberal DemocratSigned
George Galloway08/11/2004Glasgow, KelvinIndependentSigned
Denzil Davies11/11/2004LlanelliLabourSigned
Joan Ruddock15/11/2004Lewisham, DeptfordLabourSigned
Terry DavisUnknownWithdrawn

Download raw data as csv or xml.